Despite mass rallies, Italy’s fractured left fails to mount real challenge to Meloni’s rising far-right popularity

Nevin Al Sukari - Sana'a - People holding a giant Palestinian flag pass by the Colosseum as they take part in a national demonstration named "#StopRearmEU" against rearmament and promoted by over 300 networks, social organisations, trade unions, national and local politics that adhere to the European campaign "Stop Rearm Europe", which counts among its members about a thousand acronyms in 18 countries, with the Colosseum in background, in Rome on June 21, 2025. — AFP pic

ROME, July 15 — Hundreds of thousands of people attended protests in Rome last month hailed as a show of strength against Giorgia Meloni’s hard-right government, but Italy’s divided opposition is struggling to make an impact.

Almost three years after its historic election victory, Meloni’s far-right Brothers of Italy party remains the most popular, polling at 29 percent — above the 26 percent it secured in the September 2022 vote, according to the latest YouTrend survey.

The prime minister herself tops polls of party leaders with an approval rating of 45 percent, according to Ipsos.

The traditional left is struggling across Europe, where populist parties — particularly the far-right — have gained ground in recent years.

And in Italy, which once had Western Europe’s largest Communist Party, “there is a crisis in the left”, commented Paolo Borioni, professor of political science at Rome’s Sapienza University.

He said left-wing parties had “severed their historical class ties”, notably with those on lower incomes.

The opposition is dominated by the centre-left Democratic Party (PD), currently polling at around 22 percent, and the Five Star Movement, with around 13 percent.

Marc Lazar, a professor at Sciences Po Paris and Luiss University in Rome, said both are paying the price for their record in government, where they “disappointed, they did not address social issues”.

The PD adopted several measures that liberalised the labour market and cut public spending while in power after the 2013 election. Since then, they have lost over three million votes.

For its part, the Five Star triumphed in 2018 elections on an anti-establishment message, only to ally with its declared enemies while in government.

People gather around the Freedom Flotilla ship "Handala" ahead of the boat's departure for Gaza at a port in Syracuse, Sicily, southern Italy, on July 13, 2025. — AFP pic

Gaza, Ukraine

The PD chose a new leader after the 2022 elections, Elly Schlein, who has tacked further left, championing a national minimum wage and increased spending on education and healthcare.

The Five Star under former premier Giuseppe Conte is also pushing for a minimum wage and a basic income for the most vulnerable.

“Meloni, like all the right, claims to defend the people but only defends the big hedge funds, the big banks,” Riccardo Ricciardi, president of the Five Star parliamentary group in the Chamber of Deputies, told AFP.

Both parties have also sought to mobilise public concern about rising defence budgets and Israel’s offensive in Gaza.

Five Star threw its weight behind a large protest in Rome last month against rearmament, an issue that Lazar noted “poses a challenge to Giorgia Meloni” in a country with a long tradition of peace movements.

But divisions on the issue within the PD have undermined the opposition’s ability to attack the government.

Both the PD and Five Star also backed a huge protest on Gaza, but some PD supporters accused Schlein of being slow to take up the issue.

“They lack courage,” lamented Arianna D’Archivio, a 23-year-old student organiser at the rearmament protest.

A third large demonstration took place for Pride, an explicit challenge to Meloni’s socially conservative agenda.

Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni (right) shakes hands with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky (left) at the end of their press conference, as part of The Ukraine Recovery Conference 2025 (URC2025) at The Roma Convention Centre in Rome on July 10, 2025. — AFP pic

Vote alliances

Meloni shares government with the smaller far-right League party and the centre-right Forza Italia, which gives her a majority in parliament.

Despite their differences, PD and Five Star have tried teaming up at the ballot box, with joint candidates winning regional elections in Emilia-Romagna and Umbria in 2024, as well as the northern city of Genoa in May.

They also both supported a recent referendum on labour market reform, although it failed due to low turnout.

Schlein insisted the PD was making progress.

“We will happily leave the polls to Meloni’s right, but we are winning elections,” she told AFP at a recent event.

The PD performed better than expected in last year’s European Parliament elections, winning 24 percent of the vote, compared to 29 percent for Meloni’s party — but with a historically low turnout.

A man poses with a placard reading 'Meloni, your hate is a crime against humanity' during the Pride march in support of LGBTQ rights, in Rome on June 14, 2025. — AFP pic

Disconnected

For Dario Salvetti, an auto industry worker from Florence, the left is “broken”, “disconnected from the masses” in a country where salaries have been stalled for decades and one in ten Italians is classified as living in poverty.

For analyst Borioni, there is “no rightward shift in the population in Italy”, just more people are abandoning the left.

Activists meanwhile see the problem as politics, not the left itself.

Francesca Ciuffi, a 27-year-old trade unionist in the textile hub of Prato, noted their recent successes in improving conditions for workers following strikes.

“The big unions and left-wing parties have abandoned their role,” she said. — AFP